Was your family member's boarding foil denied because of the travel ban?

Two federal courts have ruled against the State Department's use of the travel-ban Proclamations to deny boarding foils to approved follow-to-join asylees. We are preparing a new case to bring the same claims for more families.

If you have asylum in the United States, USCIS approved your Form I-730, and the State Department refused your spouse or child a boarding foil because of Proclamation 10949 or 10998, you may have a claim.

Two federal courts have now reached the same practical result. Both decisions are subject to appeal, and neither strikes down the Proclamations themselves.

Who may be able to join

You may be a fit for litigation if all of the following are true:

  • You were granted asylum and you live in the United States.

  • You filed Form I-730 for your spouse or child, and USCIS approved it.

  • Your relative is outside the United States and is a national of a country covered by Proclamation 10949 or 10998.

  • The State Department refused your relative a boarding foil after an interview because of the Proclamations or INA section 212(f).

We review every case individually. These situations may not fit:

  • Your I-730 is still pending at USCIS. This case concerns State Department processing after approval.

  • The refusal rested on a different ground, such as a bar to asylum or an unresolved question about identity or relationship.

  • Your relative's petition is refugee-based rather than asylee-based.

About the Cases

A.A. v. U.S. Department of State (E.D. Va.)

Seven Afghan asylee families sued in October 2025 in the Eastern District of Virginia. On May 28, 2026, Judge Anthony Trenga denied the government's motion to dismiss. He held that the claims were reviewable and that relatives with approved I-730 petitions are, at a minimum, seeking asylum. Both Proclamations exempt people who are seeking asylum.

On July 29, 2026, the court granted summary judgment to the families. It ordered boarding foils for five derivative plaintiffs and individualized adjudication, without regard to the Proclamations, for two who had not yet been interviewed. It also vacated the State Department's policy of applying the Proclamations to deny boarding foils to follow-to-join asylees.

The government appealed (Fourth Circuit No. 26-2119). On October 1, 2026, a three-judge panel denied its request to pause the judgment during the appeal. Two of the three judges wrote that the ruling does not decide the merits.

Unless the Fourth Circuit overturns the district court’s decision, the policy to deny I-730 follow-to-join petitions solely based on the travel ban is unlawful and not in place.

A.R.R. v. Rubio (D.D.C.)

On November 2, 2026, Judge Amit Mehta of the District of Columbia ordered the State Department to readjudicate the follow-to-join plaintiffs' I-730 applications and produce boarding foils without considering the Proclamations. The deadline is 45 days. The order is final and can be appealed. The plaintiffs in this case are represented by Ariela Lake Law & Consulting.

Ariela Lake Law & Consulting is accepting families to bring individual suits or join a group, federal action. No outcome is guaranteed. The decisions described below involve other families, and they may be appealed.